COMPUTER FRAUD AND THEFT WITHIN THE THEATRE
INDUSTRY
For Theater
Owners.
This is written for Theater Owners, because when an employee steals, it is
your pocket that they are stealing from. A recent study conducted by an outside
independent agency concluded that anywhere from 5 to 20% of gross takings were
being lost due to fraud, theft, and waste. The largest examples of this became
evident when a national chain was taken for all of the summer receipts from one
of their four screen theaters. Another well known incident is the manager that
defrauded the ticket receipts for more than $ 30,000.00 over a six month period.
The reason that these incidents became common knowledge was because of the
amounts involved. These individuals got greedy. The incidents that go unreported
are the thefts that amount to $30.00 per day to $500 per week mainly because
these individuals never get caught and supplement their income. They are content
to draw their usual pay and pilfer an additional paycheck.
The most
common area for theft is the concession area. Theft can be controlled to some
degree with the implementation of computers, scanners, strict inventory controls
and other means. All of these solutions have a simple flaw, they all depend on
the manager. All of the solutions mentioned are to keep the concessionists
honest. Where the occasional concession person may pocket the extra 5 or 10
dollars a night, it is the manager that can pocket the 50 to 100 dollars without
getting caught. If the concession person comes up short a couple of times, they
are terminated. But who checks the manager ? The District or city manager
usually lacks the experience and training of what to look for regarding the
consistent theft and fraud that managers can establish. When computer systems
are integrated into a theater, usually the district or city manager has little
or no idea how to check up on the managers, therefore if the paper work looks
right, the counts of stock are right, the figures must be right. Wrong. Many of
the computer systems on the market actually help a manager fraud you. I say you
because it is your theater that is being stolen from and that is no different
than reaching into your pocket and taking the money.
The largest amounts
of money are stolen at the box office. While it is easier to steal from the
concession receipts, there is bigger money in the box office. Almost any 10th
grader with an interest in computers could "hack" into many computer ticketing
systems. This is where fraud can go unnoticed for years. Lets take, for example,
one of your 10 screen theaters who for the past 5 years has always done well,
average to above average grosses with a constant per capita, would you miss 10
tickets a night ? At $6.00 per ticket that is only $60.00 per night. Not a major
amount but this comes out of your pocket and lets say the manager actually
closes 4 nights a week, now that is $240.00 per week or an extra tax free
$12,000 per year ( two weeks off, paid vacation). This is an example of a
manager who is not greedy, a thief yes, but not greedy.
Because the
theft is a relativity small amount it is not suspicious and it can never be
tracked because the sales never show up with many computer systems. The manager
simply deletes the tickets or arranges for the computer to never record some
tickets numbers to a particular show and runs the computer reports just like
normal. Nobody is going to miss 10 or 15 tickets on a movie that did 150 - 300
tickets that day. Hard tickets are even easier, with the reselling of ticket
stubs, etc. There are several other methods of stealing but most of the others
involve additional personnel and that in itself causes problems for the thieves.
The more people that know or are involved, the greater the chance of getting
caught.
Most of the computer systems available today give you the tools
or access to the tools to perpetrate this crime against you. The same companies
that you are paying 10 to 100 thousand dollars to computerize your theater are
providing your managers with the means of frauding you and the film companies of
your full receipts. Most MS-DOS TM , Windows TM , Windows 95 TM, Windows NT TM,
and other common network solutions can, will, and have been frauded.
The
next time you are at the mall, go into one of the computer stores and just
glance in the Utilities software section. There you will find all the programs,
priced from $25 to $75 dollars, that your manager could purchase that will allow
your computer system to be frauded. These programs are simple to use and come
with detailed instructions. Many software companies will refute this information
saying that their data is encrypted and there are checks and balances that
prevent this from happening. While you are in the Utilities section of that
computer store, check the encryption and Unencryption programs available too. No
data that is accessible is secure.
There are other ways of frauding a
computer system that have nothing to do with having any computer knowledge at
all. One of the simplest, netted one manager almost $10,000 before he got to
greedy and got caught. The methods mentioned here were mainly done by one person
without the knowledge of any one else in the theater knowing what was going on.
It can easily be hidden from the employees, assistant managers and other
colleagues.
What can you do as a theater owner to make sure that you are
actually getting all of your receipts ? Invest in a quality computer system, not
necessarily the most expensive because that just adds insult to injury when your
super expensive computer system is frauded, but one from a reputable company
that has no history of being frauded. A company that can explain why the system
is not susceptible to the types of fraud mentioned here and can back it up
(Details of how to fraud ticketing systems have been left out so your managers
don't get ideas). Talk to other theater owners and find out what kind of system
they use, would they use it again and why? Check out how often the system "goes
down" and how long it takes to get it working again. Make sure that the company
has a good service department. The computer being down is a quick way to pocket
numerous tickets if the service department could not be reached or took too long
to respond. Do your homework and find out what kind of system the program runs
on and check out the computer store for ways to break into that system or
application. ( Operating Systems are MS-DOS TM , Windows TM , Windows 95, 98, or
2000 TM, Windows NT TM - Applications are MS Access TM, dBase TM, Foxpro TM, C
TM, C++TM, Delphi TM, Visual Basic TM) Check with your own "computer expert"
about these type systems. Have your district or general manager work with the
ticketing company to become educated on how to look for fraud or other
suspicious things from the system. After all, it's your money.